Debra Shetlar, MD
Ophthalmology Physician · Houston, TX 77030 · NPI 1295736395 · 3 payer files
73%of Medicare
Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas — Blue Essentials pays Debra Shetlar, MD $70.75 for a 99213 — Office visit, established patient, low complexity. Medicare pays $96.33 for the same service in this locality. Commercial insurance is widely assumed to pay above Medicare. The file lists 8 contract rows for this clinician and code, from $51.98 to $95.87; the median is shown.
Negotiated rates vs Medicare
| Service | Payer · plan | Negotiated | Medicare | % of Medicare | Among Houston ophthalmology physicians, same plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 99213Office visit, established patient, low complexity | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas — Blue Essentials | $70.75median of 8 rows · $51.98–$95.87 | $96.33 | 73% | above 84% of 180 Houston ophthalmology physicians on this plan |
| Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $96.69median of 2 rows · $78.91–$114.47 | $96.33 | 100% | above 74% of 32 Houston ophthalmology physicians on this plan | |
| Aetna — Texas (office visit and psychotherapy codes only) | $112.50median of 8 rows · $85.33–$139.67 | $96.33 | 117% | above 85% of 170 Houston ophthalmology physicians on this plan | |
| 99214Office visit, established patient, moderate complexity | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas — Blue Essentials | $106.18median of 8 rows · $80.13–$140.45 | $137.41 | 77% | above 82% of 180 Houston ophthalmology physicians on this plan |
| Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $144.66median of 2 rows · $121.69–$167.64 | $137.41 | 105% | above 74% of 32 Houston ophthalmology physicians on this plan | |
| Aetna — Texas (office visit and psychotherapy codes only) | $162.46median of 8 rows · $125.67–$199.24 | $137.41 | 118% | above 85% of 169 Houston ophthalmology physicians on this plan |
Also contracted — outside this specialty’s usual billing
| Service | Payer · plan | Negotiated | Medicare | % of Medicare | Among Houston ophthalmology physicians, same plan |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 90833Psychotherapy, 30 minutes, add-on to an office visit | Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $104.57median of 2 rows · $101.02–$108.13 | $82.68 | 126% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians |
| Aetna — Texas (office visit and psychotherapy codes only) | $108.58median of 8 rows · $97.28–$119.88 | $82.68 | 131% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians | |
| 90838Psychotherapy, 60 minutes, add-on to an office visit | Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $174.88median of 2 rows · $169.13–$180.62 | $138.62 | 126% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians |
| 70553MRI brain, with and without contrast | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas — Blue Essentials | $204.26median of 8 rows · $88.84–$408.31 | $317.92 | 64% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians |
| Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $572.07 | $317.92 | 180% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians | |
| 72148MRI lumbar spine, without contrast | Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $341.06 | $192.38 | 177% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians |
| 74177CT abdomen and pelvis, with contrast | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas — Blue Essentials | $182.64median of 8 rows · $70.74–$386.44 | $300.72 | 61% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians |
| Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $492.15 | $300.72 | 164% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians | |
| 77067Screening mammography, bilateral | Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas — Blue Essentials | $85.40median of 4 rows · $45.41–$161.89 | $126.38 | 68% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians |
| Cigna — Houston FlexCare | $210.20 | $126.38 | 166% | not typically billed by ophthalmology physicians |
A payer’s file carries a rate for every code in the contract’s fee class, whether or not the clinician will ever bill it. These rows are real, and they are how the fee class shows through — but they are not evidence that Debra Shetlar, MD performs these services, and they are kept out of the benchmark above.